Openness and Transparency are essential for progress. Sadly, most scientific publication processes obscure both.
Thankfully, in mathematics, physics, computer science, and related fields there’s the arXiv, a pre-print server where authors can post their papers long before they’ve gone through the peer-review process.
It’s just reached 1 Million pre-prints. I’m looking forward to the continued overtaking of the traditional scientific-publishing industry by formats such as this.
The arXiv has become a default for these more “hardcore” of the hard sciences. For instance, when Perelman proved the Poincare conjecture, he ONLY published it on the arXiv (and then refused a fields medal).
The popularity of the arXiv server has varied among disciplines. Some physicists were reluctant at first to share their results before formal, peer-reviewed publication, but came around to the idea when they realized the benefits of a quick way to publicize their work. For example, the discovery of a class of iron-based superconductors in 2008 brought a host of condensed-matter experimentalists to the site, “won over by the need to stake precedence claims and get their results in front of theorists”, Ginsparg wrote in his 2011 piece.
Nowadays, many important findings are posted first at the site. When the reclusive Russian mathematician Grigori Perelman proved the Poincaré conjecture (a statement about the nature of three-dimensional spaces that had resisted proof for almost a century), he posted his papers only at arXiv.org, and nowhere else. (Perelman later declined a Fields medal for the work).
When the POINT is the advancement of knowledge, places like the arXiv provide an invaluable service. Also check out the bioRxiv!
Now go lift something heavy,
pps. That’s Perelman in the pic.